Best NHL Player Props Today — Top Picks for Wednesday, May 20, 2026

Wednesday, May 20, 2026, brings high-stakes NHL action, and the player prop markets are offering some intriguing opportunities for sharp bettors. As the playoffs deepen, individual player roles become more pronounced, making statistical projections more reliable. Today, we focus on three standout props that offer significant value based on recent performance trends, matchup advantages, and line movement at sportsgameodds.

Cale Makar Over 0.5 Plus/Minus (-172)

The Colorado Avalanche's defenseman Cale Makar is the engine of their offense, and his plus-minus line of 0.5 at -172 suggests a strong probability of him finishing with a positive rating. Makar consistently plays in all situations, including the power play and penalty kill, giving him ample opportunities to impact the scoreboard.

Key factors supporting the over:

• Offensive Zone Starts: Makar averages high-quality offensive zone starts, leading to more goal-scoring chances.
• Power Play Unit: With the Avalanche's potent power play, Makar is a primary quarterback, increasing his assist and goal potential.
• Defensive Reliability: His ability to shut down opposing top lines helps secure positive plus-minus outcomes in close games.

At -172, the implied probability is roughly 63.3%. Given Makar's consistent minute distribution and offensive upside, this line offers solid value for a player who rarely finishes negative in meaningful games.

Artturi Lehkonen Over 1.5 Shots on Goal (+115)

Looking for some value on the odds side? Artturi Lehkonen's shots on goal line is set at 1.5 with the over priced at +115. Lehkonen is a relentless forechecker and a consistent presence on the Avalanche's top line. His playing style involves frequent shots from the slot and the point.

Why the over is the play:

• Shot Volume: Lehkonen has been averaging over 2.5 shots per game in recent outings.
• Matchup Advantage: The opposing defense has struggled to clear the crease, leading to higher shot attempts for Avalanche wingers.
• Power Play Time: Additional PP opportunities further boost his shot totals.

The +115 odds represent a positive expected value (+EV) bet, making it one of the smartest plays on the board for Wednesday.

Mackenzie Blackwood Over 23.5 Saves (-130)

Goalie props can be tricky, but Mackenzie Blackwood's 23.5 save line at -130 looks manageable. Blackwood tends to face a moderate volume of shots, and his team's defensive structure supports a save total above this threshold. The opponent has been generating consistent shot attempts, which benefits the goalie's save count.

Supporting statistics:

• Recent Save Percentage: Blackwood has maintained a save percentage above .910 in his last five starts.
• Shot Against Average: He faces approximately 28-30 shots per game, making the over 23.5 a safe baseline.
• Pace of Play: The opposing team plays a deliberate, possession-based game, leading to sustained offensive pressure.

While -130 requires a significant wager to yield profit, the consistency of Blackwood's role makes this a reliable play for bankroll management.

Other Notable Mentions

In addition to our top picks, keep an eye on Devon Toews Over 0.5 Plus/Minus (-156) and Sam Malinski Over 1.5 Shots on Goal (+140). Toews provides steady defensive stability for the Avalanche, while Malinski's offensive contributions are increasing, offering another +EV shot on the shots prop.

Remember to check sportsgameodds for the latest line movements before placing your bets. Good luck on Wednesday!